It’s 7:00 AM on a Saturday and I have just finished watching the Torchwood: Children of Earth 5 part-miniseries. For those of you non-geeks out there, Torchwood is a science-fiction show made by the BBC set in the Doctor Who universe (c’mon, you know Doctor Who, right?) about a team of specialists in Cardiff Wales who regularly save the Earth from aliens (if you want the dirty deets, click here) . Some of the episodes were great, some were really not, but the writing, the cast, the premise, and the plot lines stayed with me long after the episode ended. So, after an 18-month hiatus, I was really looking forward to this mini-series, which was basically all the BBC was giving we fans in terms of a third season of the show. And, after watching the thing, I have come to some conclusions about TV writers/creators, particularly those in the sci-fi fantasy genre:
The bastards are the worst kind of evil-genius-sadists that ever frakking lived.
Take Joss Whedon, profilic writer and the mastermind behind Buffy the Vampire Slayer, Angel, Firefly, and now Dollhouse. He took a series and not only used it as a symbolic commentary on contemporary issues (high school is rough anyway – now try being a high school sophomore with a secret identity in a town overrun by the undead), but as a chance to fully develop living, breathing, human characters, that screw up and make mistakes and invite fans to really, fully emotionally attach to them. As a fan, I cared about the characters in those shows, enough to regularly forget what most of the fans of the original Star Trek forgot – it’s just a show, those aren’t real people, so don’t get so upset when bad things happen to them. The fact that I did get upset when Buffy had to kill Angel at the end of the 2nd season points (I hope) less to the fact that I am an enormous geek and more to the fact that Joss Whedon is a freaking brilliant writer who could make me care about his characters just as though they were real people.
So, take it as a given – Joss Whedon, Eric Kripke (Supernatural), and Russell T Davies (Doctor Who, Torchwood), like all good writers, have the power to make me, as a fan, care, and care deeply, about the fictional characters they create.
But with that power comes great responsibility, right? Not necessarily.
It used to be, back in the good old days, that there was an unwritten, cardinal rule, an unspoken bond of trust between writers and their fans. That commandment was simple. Thou shall not kill a major character.
(In the Sci Fi universe, that commandment is amended to Thou shall not permanently kill a major character.)
Put them in mortal peril if you must, even kill them (with the understanding that, through some otherwordly means, you’ll bring them back), but give us some hope that things will eventually turn out all right. That’s why we read the series, or watch the show, as fans – in the hope that somehow, some way, these people we care about will eventually prevail and everything will be all right.
Seriously, that’s all we want, writers. If your creative process means that every week you feel the need to rip my beating out of my chest and leave me a hollowed, sobbing, empty shell of a person, go ahead – I’ll put up with it as long as I have some faint hope that, eventually, at least by the series end for God’s sake, everything will turn out okay. That’s all I ask.
So, when I hear talk on the Supernatural boards about sending the heroes out to die in a blaze of glory at the end of the series, or Russell T Davies decides that the best way to showcase the world going to hell is to utterly destroy team Torchwood until the few remaining characters are broken down, beaten shells of themselves with no hope of a happy ending, I get the strong urge to track those guys down and smack them on the back of the head until they figure out that they’re not living up to their end of the bargain.
What bargain, you may ask. Those characters belong to them, they’re the creative geniuses behind them, they’re allowed to do what they want without regard to the fans, right?
I disagree. Books, shows, whatever, are not created in a vacuum. If I’m writing a story for myself, then sure, I’ll do whatever I want. But, especially in TV, the fans are what make a show live. They’re what keep it on the air, or keep those DVD sales going after the series ends. If, as a writer, the show creator loves his characters, then he ought to want them to live on, to leave a legacy, where people are still enjoying and reading and watching and caring about them long after the writer has moved on to other things. And if you’ve got to end everything, then end it on a high note, so those of us who love those characters can imagine them keeping on doing what they were doing, living their lives and saving the world, even if we can’t see them doing it any more.
Doyle learned it firsthand when he tried to kill off Holmes in Reichenbach Falls, and the public outcry was so great he was forced to bring him back. Fans give characters life. A storyteller is nothing without an audience.
I don’t read fantasy and sci-fi, or watch it, because I need more reality in my life; I read it because I need a break from it. So please, showrunners, writers, what-have-you, please STOP thinking that the only way you can illustrate your amazing talent is to break the norm and give me a horrible, angst-filled, hopeless ending where all the people I’ve spent years caring about are dead. Remember your audience – put yourself in my place.
And give me my damn heart back.